When Anthony and Kimberly Teeter first walked into Carelli’s Pizzeria, they weren’t looking for a business. They were on vacation. But what began as a trip to visit family quickly turned into a new chapter — not just for them but for the food culture of Craig.

After years of visiting, the Teeters decided to make Craig their home in 2020. A native of the Bronx, Anthony spent two decades as an NYPD officer, many times working in Italian neighborhoods filled with pizzerias and family restaurants.