Carmelo’s Pizzeria serves up Italian classics in a cozy atmosphere

Apr 19, 2017 311


Joe and Cindy Tringali have cornered the market on King and Malaga streets in downtown St. Augustine with their popular pizzeria, Carmelo’s Pizzeria. What started out as a small gas station named Conner’s Shell 25 years ago has grown into a booming business comprised of a gas station, an upscale marketplace and a pizzeria.

New York-style pizza is cooked in a brick oven at temperatures between 550-600 degrees. Sicilian pizza is also on the menu. Calzones, strombolis, spaghetti and meatballs and other traditional Italian entrees are served as well as salads, subs and a sprinkling of appetizers. Don’t miss the homemade desserts.

Read more


You may be interested